Book 9 opens with a personal prologue: Milton, genre-conscious as ever, discusses the hybrid genres of Paradise Lost, and justifies his arduous poetic project. With Raphael’s departure from Paradise, the poem is said to be, from here on, of the tragic-heroic mode. Book 9 will tell of the tragedy of humanity’s Fall, and it is in this book that the fatal act of disobedience will take place.
Milton intends to redefine classical heroism in Christian terms, he says; he means to demonstrate how the narrative of the Fall, its consequences and Christ’s salvation — the novel subject for his Christian epic — is superior to traditional heroic subjects for its lofty portrait of ‘patience and heroic martyrdom’.
The poem turns to Satan. Having compassed the earth for more than a week, Satan finally decides to sneak back into Paradise, plotting humanity’s destruction. Concealed by the darkness, and ‘involved in rising mist’, Satan infiltrates the garden, and proceeds to roam the Earth in search of a serpent to disguise himself with.
Satan bursts into passionate lament. Tortured by his inner inability to enjoy the delights of Earth’s beauty, and consumed with hate and jealousy, he soliloquises on his inward grief. His bestial form and fall from Godhead disgust him, but ambition and revenge have debased him beyond redemption: his only desire is to spite God and bring about humanity’s destruction. Satan finds a sleeping serpent to possess. He enters it through its mouth, and lies in wait.
As day dawns, Eve suggests that they divide their labours in the garden to work more effectively. Adam admits the sense of Eve's suggestion, and despite voicing at some length his fear that their separation might expose her to Satan’s temptation, after which the pair debate rather tensely, he eventually allows her to go. The narrator proclaims against this folly, unable to let the 'event perverse' (405) pass without lament.
Satan catches sight of Eve, and is momentarily disarmed by ‘[h]er heavenly form / Angelic’. Before long, he talks himself back into hatred. He approaches Eve in glittering serpentine form, ready to begin his ‘fraudulent temptation’.
Satan opens in flattering tones, with a high-flying encomium to Eve’s beauty and sovereignty. Eve marvels at the serpent's human voice. Satan leads her to the very tree which he alluringly claims gave him the powers of Reason and Speech. She resists when she discovers it is the forbidden Tree of Knowledge, but Satan persists, tempting her with persuasive arguments about the boundless knowledge and enfranchisement that could be hers if only she tasted the ‘intellectual fruit’.
Astonished by Satan's skilled command of language and Reason, persuaded by his flattery, and in hunger of knowledge, liberty and Godhead, Eve persuades herself to succumb:
Forth-reaching to the Fruit, she plucked, she eat.
Earth felt the wound, and Nature from her seat,
Sighing through all her works, gave signs of woe
That all was lost.
Eve feels the greedy rush of knowledge. She considers keeping its fruits to herself: with ‘the odds of knowledge in [her] power’ she may finally be able to live as Adam’s ‘equal’, ‘for, inferior, who is free?’. Nevertheless, afraid to lose Adam, jealous that he may take another wife if the fruit does prove to be fatal, she decides to bring her spouse a sample.
Adam is horrified by Eve’s transgression, but he cannot bear to be separated from her, even if it means facing death. He resolves to follow the only path his love allows: he completes the ‘mortal sin / Original’ by eating the fruit.
Intoxicated, the pair are filled with carnal lust. After making love, they wake to find themselves miserably naked. Scrambling to cover themselves with fig leaves, they are filled, for the first time, with immeasurable shame, and weep in the face of their lost innocence. With Adam and Eve now enslaved to their passions, the turbulent powers of ‘anger, hate, / Mistrust, suspicion, discord’ take over. Book 9 ends with the pair arguing bitterly.